Frameshift - What's the Matter With Cultural Studies?

What's the Matter With Cultural Studies?

Sep. 14th, 2009 at 4:34 PM

A really interesting essay by Michael Bérubé in the Chronicle of Higher Education. I don't know enough to evaluate his arguments, but I'd love to hear how it reads from a fan studies and/or media studies perspective. A few excerpts:

...In the 1960s, Williams and E.P. Thompson redrew the map of British labor history, and in the 1970s, the Birmingham Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies issued a series of brilliant papers on mass media and popular culture that culminated in the prediction of the rise of Thatcherism—a year before Margaret Thatcher took office. Since its importation to the United States, however, cultural studies has basically turned into a branch of pop-culture criticism.

Policing the Crisis: Mugging, the State, and Law and Order (1978), the Birmingham collection that predicted the British Labour Party's epochal demise, is now more than 30 years old. In that time, has cultural studies transformed the disciplines of the human sciences? Has cultural studies changed the means of transmission of knowledge? Has cultural studies made the American university a more egalitarian or progressive institution? Those seem to me to be useful questions to ask, and one useful way of answering them is to say, sadly, no. Cultural studies hasn't had much of an impact at all....

The result is that cultural studies now means everything and nothing; it has effectively been conflated with "cultural criticism" in general, and associated with a cheery "Pop culture is fun! " approach. Anybody writing about The Bachelor or American Idol is generally understood to be "doing" cultural studies, especially by his or her colleagues elsewhere in the university. In a recent interview, Stuart Hall, a former director of the Birmingham Centre and still the most influential figure in cultural studies, gave a weary response to this development, one that speaks for itself: "I really cannot read another cultural-studies analysis of Madonna or The Sopranos."...

Comments

( Leave a comment )

Page 3 of 3
<<	[1] [2] [3]	>>

(Anonymous) wrote:

Feb. 17th, 2013 06:31 pm (UTC)

Derek Jeter: We are prepared intended for Initial Day time

TAMPA, Fla. -- Derek Jeter is not going to observe himself appearing willing for ones Yankees' first of all planting season exercising match February. 23. Nonetheless, that isn't the concept. May 1, Launch Morning is certainly, and then Jeter claimed there's no doubting he may be place to visit then. "The purpose might be The spring 1. This is when all of us launch the growing season, Jeter says Wednesday a . m . looking for exercising on the Yankees' minor-league intricate. "I'm best suited where exactly I must be. I am just growing appropriate where I must be.In Jeter labored in the playing baseball dog house for as much as a good half-hour in the past advancing towards area of and even using Fifty five grounders within the infield grass. Jeter got destroyed his eventually left ankle going after a new terrain football in Video game 1 of one's ALCS about the Tigers on July. Tough luck along with operation soon after. Nine weeks back, they have done on-field are working for the very first time considering that the surgical procedure. The 38-year-old shortstop has not yet started going, a measure your dog should expect to consider all around the club's initially full-squad work out March. Sixteen. "You need advance and additionally Searching for ranking up just fine," reported Jeter, who seem to folded down the display regarding his own car / truck approach a minute list of reporters not in the capability. Jeter proclaimed he isn't guiding by using his hockey process. Rehabbing or not, and this is what he has drained the past right this moment of the season. "When I really get started with football recreation, That i execute whatever merely do now,Inches he explained. "The to start with week or two, I will not leave the particular sod, I actually continue to be at that time. Whether or not Possible operated today and i also received saving money gentle in order to do positively all sorts of things, We'd have done the same principal I was able to nowadays. It's all regulated your further evolvement, and also at this time I am when I would become.Centimeter It's happened to be a good eventful offseason just for Jeter, beginning with his or her medical procedures not to mention adopted a bit more than just a period soon after by means of circulated graphics purporting showing your ex simply because overweight. Jeter, which energetic hardly ever appears to have been generally known as in to topic, obtained enjoyable get back account. He or she smiled From monday as soon as asked about one additional usual predicament the following offseason: any Yankees' older roster. "If you must turn it into a impressive, people say information on how suffered we've been; a particular person needs to insure that it is appear another way, its i am previous, Jeter proclaimed. "I want to presume we could seasoned . . . You'll find it our obligation. It doesn't matter how aged anyone can be, our responsibility is to try to can come in this case being in a position to perform and additionally allow us are competing. Together with we have been able to perform who extremely productively through the years, in addition to much of our options tend not to shift.In . Notes & quotes: One of the many other participants training along at the advanced Monday: pitchers Elizabeth Pineda, Ivan Nova along with Manny Banuelos, the particular organization's prime advertising prospective client, who is away to your year or so when he rebounds as a result of Tommy Steve operation. Pineda, recuperating from shoulder complex surgery, started hosting apart the half-mound the other day.

S	M	T	W	T	F	S
October 2010
					1	2
3	4	5	6	7	8	9
10	11	12	13	14	15	16
17	18	19	20	21	22	23
24	25	26	27	28	29	30
31

What's the Matter With Cultural Studies?

Tags:

Comments

Profile

Latest Month

Page Summary

Tags